Muslimah

Pigs on buses

31 posts in this topic

as salam alykom

I got this from another board:

Question: Latest news reports say that the Israeli Government is preparing to place pigs on buses and other places so that the Mujahideen who carry out martyrdom opperations will touch the pigs before they die and hence be "denied entry to paradise"

"Though the pig is considered a defiled animal strictly forbidden in Jewish dietary laws, the Muslims forbid any contact with the animal. Any contact with the pig is punishable by denial of entry to paradise."

Is it true that any contact with a pig before death denies entry to paradise? If this is true, then will the shuhada (martyrs) still be considered shuhada? Or will the Palestinians have to quit martyrdom opperations in locations where pig is suspected to be?

Answer: Yes, it is a sin to keep or transact in pigs. However, involuntary, accidental, or unwitting contact with pigs is not even a sin, let alone something that would prevent entry into paradise.

And Allah knows best.

Wassalam,

Faraz Rabbani (faraz@sunnipath.com)

Sunni Path - www.sunnipath.com

any comments????

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

alsalam 'alaykom

When jews do this, it means that they know that palestenian martyrs go to heaven by will of Allah, and that they are envious of that, but they are ignorant of so many simple things in relegion, or they think that muslims are ignorant of theirs. I think that now the operations will increase and not decrease. LoL really do they think that the palestenians will be afraid of being in contact with these pigs, and yes they will not touch them intentionaly for sure, anyways they will blow everbody up before touching any of these creatures biggrin.gif, Wasalam 'alaykom wa rahamt Allah wa Barakatuh

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally posted by Muslimah

as salam alykom

I got this from another board:

Question: Latest news reports say that the Israeli Government is preparing to place pigs on buses and other places so that the Mujahideen who carry out martyrdom opperations will touch the pigs before they die and hence be \"denied entry to paradise\"

any comments????

I have one....

Does anyone else want to know the REAL reason there will be pigs on buses?

Because pigs are more intelligent than dogs, and can smell better than dogs.

This isn't a zainy jewish plot to send muslims to hell

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally posted by Muslimah

as salam alykom

I got this from another board:

Question: Latest news reports say that the Israeli Government is preparing to place pigs on buses and other places so that the Mujahideen who carry out martyrdom opperations will touch the pigs before they die and hence be \"denied entry to paradise\"

how ignorant! they think they can fool ALLAH.

ps: suicide bombers are not martyrs. Not according to our religion islam, there is a huge difference between jihad and suicide bombers.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Asalaamu alikum,

I think we should be careful in saying who is a martyr and who is not. Allah knows best what is in our hearts and He is the best of Judges.

May Allah guide us and have mercy on us all, Ameen.

~Jennifer

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally posted by SisterJennifer

Asalaamu alikum,

I think we should be careful in saying who is a martyr and who is not.  Allah knows best what is in our hearts and He is the best of Judges.

May Allah guide us and have mercy on us all, Ameen.

~Jennifer

Is not the Quran the inspired word of Allah?

And does not the Quran say that all care must be taken to try to avoid women and children in Jihad?

And thus, does that not mean that bombs in familiy restaraunts are indiscriminate killings, as well as ignoring the word of the Quran?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Because pigs are more intelligent than dogs, and can smell better than dogs.

oh really is that true, I never heard of such a thing before, well maybe y not.smile.gif

ps: suicide bombers are not martyrs. Not according to our religion islam, there is a huge difference between jihad and suicide bombers.

We leave this to Allah, not us, he knows best, as sister jennifer said, all Islamic scholars say it is their right as self defense, so the judge to decide is Allah Almighty and not us.

Is not the Quran the inspired word of Allah?

And does not the Quran say that all care must be taken to try to avoid women and children in Jihad?

And thus, does that not mean that bombs in familiy restaraunts are indiscriminate killings, as well as ignoring the word of the Quran?

Correct Phat, it is haram to kill women children and elderly in war, even animals or cutting trees or blowing houses or churches

or any worship place for christians or jews, except for those who worship idols and statues, they are to be broken. So Allah only knows if they are martyrs or not and he will ask them about those innocent souls insha'Alla(by will of Allah). But I still say we are not in their place, if we were, we never know what we might do, and especially now after bush agreed to sharon's plan, may Allah help us to what will happen in the next coming days, the region will blow up I guess,:confused:.

May Allah help us and be our guidance.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

How far wont these yahud go

may allah strengthen us against the evil within them

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally posted by radiyah

all Islamic scholars say it is their right as self defense.

"All"?, sorry but I don't believe that to be true, All scholars and ulemas most definitely don't agree on this issue, and

Shaykh Uthaymeen, rahimullah, Shaykh Nasr ul deen Albani, raheemullah, Shayk Bin Baz, Raheemullah and others, are all very respected and pious scholars who speak against suicide and they say it is Haram.

Please find me a verse of hadith that says you can kill yourself (i.e die at your OWN hands, not the enemies during battle) and kill civilians going about their daily business whilst your at it. Find something from Islam that says you can do that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

as salam alykom

what intrested me in this post is the fact that Jews clealy admitted that Islam is true and Muslims who die fighting go to Jannah. Regardless of the disparity among scholars on this issue. I read several fatwas about it, I prefer not to judge and leave it to Allah.

However, again I fully agree with SisterJennifer. No one can actually call any dead person during a battle a martyre simply because only Allah knows the intention. Not only if the person carries an arm and fights boldy until killed. It all depends on the intention as in anything else, even posting here.

Alhamdulelah may Allah correct our intentions

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dear intuition, I am not here to win a debate, yes it is haram to kill one self and commit suicide, that is true, it is haram to kill civilians it is true, but I watch many relegious programs, on saudi chanel and Iqraa and the scholars say that they have the right and this is not suicide(and their fatwa on this only regarding the palestenians, and not other suicide bombers, like 9/11 and the madrid explosion, and what ever like it, but this is the palestenians land, the jews have no right to live in it, they stole it, and they are in state of war with them, with all Islam, and no one of the arab or muslim world leaders are doing anything to stop what is hapening to them, money sent to them taken by others, I do not want to mention names, so he has no other way to fight, when your house is blown your sister raped your mother and father killed, your new born baby killed, what would u do then intuition, just sit and say yes come and kill me too I will be very happy and pleased, in palestine and now Iraq((yesterday I saw an interview with a saudi doctor who entered Iraq to help them, and he said frightning facts of what is hapeining there and not being showed or not allowed to be shown by media, he is a doctor at the saudi hospital in jeddah, he says the americans are not allowing food or medical aid to be sent to faloja, or any other part in Iraq, they even bombed the malyzian red crescent who were carying lots of medecin and aids for the Iraqi's we only c what the jews and americans want us to c through the media, no one knows what is truly happening inside there)), women are being raped, killed also children, and then u tell me they have no right to defend themselves.

I will tell u a story here .On the day of the fto7at when the muslims were spreading Islam, There was one castle that the muslims could not open, so one muslim said to his companions carry me and throw me into it and i will open it for u or die, and may Allah accept me as shaheed, there was a small hole in the castle,they threw him, and it was opened and the muslims won, and he knew he might die, but he is giving his life for a sacred purpose for Islam to spread, and it was not conciderd suicide, I do not remember the sahaby name right now or in what battle, I will look it up for u and post it.

and also in surrat Al-burooj

http://www.tafsir.com/default.asp?sid=85&tid=57727

read here the surra and the tafseer, u will c how the muslims at that time were forced to throw themselves in the ditch of fire, and the the story of the pious boy, he knew he will die, but on the other side everybody embraced Islam. u will tell me it is not the same concept, when blowing yourself up, I will still insist and tell u it is all in Allah's hand, he decides if they are martyrs or not and it depends on their intention.

So we will leave it to Allah, and we do not say if they are martyrs or not.

We just pray that may Allah accept them.

If I am right it is from Allah, if I am mistaken is from my Ignorance and little knowledge.

Wasalam 'laykom wa rahmat Allah wa barakatuh

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally posted by radiyah

he says the americans are not allowing food or medical aid to be sent to faloja, or any other part in Iraq,

We are changing the thread, but the least you could do is give me, as an American, the respect of telling the entire story in context (or perhaps it is this doctor who does not wisht to give me that respect).

Food and medicine stopped going to Falluja when ALL traffic stopped going to Falluja - why did this happen?? Because 4 American workers who were BRINGING food and medicine to the area were killed, burned, mutilated, and hung for the disgusting people in the area to see.

People complain that food and medicine is not going - yet when it was, they killed these contractors.

Since the ceasefire, shipments have continued, but let's try to make sure statements are whole,and not just demonizing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Salaam Alaikum!

When all else fails, send in the pork!

Israel's new tactic to "suppress" terror is of course going to spark outrage amongst the Muslims in Palestine and elsewhere in the pax Islamica.

But, has anyone questioned the logics of this? Placing pigs on the bus will not only prevent peaceful Muslims from entering, but will also defect observant and orthodox Jews. It baffles me, really. However, the response to that, is, that as long as it's in "defense", there's nothing wrong with using the pig as a defensive stratagem.

Do I believe that's true? Nope! These are the same Rabbi's and Judeologues who have repetitively tried to "liberalize" or better put, "G-rate" an "X-rated" and pornographic biblical past. I'm not surprised by this tactic. In a similar vein, demolishing homes of Palestinians goes against Jewish law. Did those Torah abiding Israeli's (the radicals) condemn such? Nay! I don't suspect the pig fiasco will subside either.

More seriously, the terrorists believe they're on a divine mission. Porky Pig won't stutter or stagger their unequivocal pursuit to their teleological end.

Ibn

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bismillah

Phat you are now generalizing as well when you say... "and hung for the disgusting people in the area to see." Not everyone is participating in the fighting. In fact there are people who are trying to leave but if a man who the US deems is battle aged is with them, he cannot leave. (Source: An article from my local paper.) Families thus decide to stay together instead of being seperated and possibly never seeing each other again.

I agree that we should try not to lump people into one group. We must also do this with the residents of Fujallah. There ARE people caught in the middle of this violence who want nothing more than to just escape.

If I percieved your statement in correctly, then please let me know. Appreciate it.

Peace.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Originally posted by Dan

If I percieved your statement in correctly, then please let me know.  Appreciate it.  

Peace.

You did. When I said 'for the disgusting people to see' I did not mean the general populous of the area, but instead, it is only logical that the bodies were hung for two groups:

1>Those that do not violently oppose the coalition, and they were hung as an insult/threat/etc. Men with guns threatened a nurse who attempted to take the body down.

2>Those that violently oppose the coalition. Clearly, as a sign to them that attacking works, and to give whatever sick gratification comes to that group. This is the disgusting group I speak of.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

as salam alykom

To the best of my knowledge, and I am no scholar, we are commanded not to mutilate bodies even of non muslims during war battles. But humans make mistakes. May Allah allow us all to improve.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

More seriously, the terrorists believe they're on a divine mission.

Excuse me Ibn, do u consider palestenians as terrorists, u being a muslim?:confused:

We are changing the thread, but the least you could do is give me, as an American, the respect of telling the entire story in context (or perhaps it is this doctor who does not wisht to give me that respect).

Phat, the american army fired at the malyzian red crescent when it started entering from the Kuwaity boarders, long before reaching Faluja even. And what happened to those americans is disgusting, no body accepts it, not in any relegion or beleif, they are criminals yes, and I wish they catch them because I think that these are Sadam's men, because no one is more inhumane

than his men. But still the americans are not dealing with this situation in the correct way. Look at the japanese governement how they succeeded in releasing their captives. I dont know why u always take things very personally, we do not hate american people, on the contrary we hate no one, we have thousands of muslim american brothers and sisters, even in the american army, we know that there are muslims there, I really feel sorry for them, having left their home and family never knowing they will go back home or not, it is just what your governement is doing that is all Phat. from one war to another, when is this going to end I dont know. unless u are happy with what is Bush doing, then I have nothing else to say.

Peace

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(bismillah

(Assalam) Radiyah

I am not to speak on behalf of Ibn but I just would like to clarify something. He means that in Islamic jihad we must avoid killing women and children that is why he lablelled them as terrorists.

Am I not correct Ibn?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Salaam Alaikum

I think Muslimah answered the question from radiyah. I only meant those who kill the innocent. I believe there are loads of Palestinians who are "freedom" fighters and take the battle to the IDF; I do not object to that. We must reach an Islamic end by Islamic means. When we sacrafice our values at the alter of emotion, then we become no better than Israel.

If I offended the Palestinians or you individiaully, radiyah--please forgive my approach.

Ibn

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(Walikum) Ibn

ok but let me raise a point here, which I mentioned to u on a different thread. Ribat is one of the highest forms of jihad which is to protect Muslim land borders against non muslim attacks.

this is one, on a hadeeth it says what means that one who dies defending his land is a shaheed, defending his money is a shaheed or defending his a`rd which is honor is a shaheed. So we are talking about totally two different groups. Comes now to killing women and children. Yes this is a mistake, but even during the companions, they made mistakes during jihad. They were not thrown out of Allah ' s mercy or had their level of strive diminished.

we must never put Muslims and non Muslims in one category when talking about this issue specially. Palestine of all Muslim land is also different due to the Aqsa.

Hope I am making sense to u. I have more to say, but dont want to prolong the post.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(Assalam) Ibn

again till u back

look at this Ayah:

"Those who believe, fight in the Cause of Allâh, and those who disbelieve, fight in the cause of Tâghût (Satan).[1] So fight you against the friends of Shaitân (Satan). Ever feeble indeed is the plot of Shaitân (Satan)." (Quran 4:76)

This is the criteria, u can not equate those who fight in the cause of Allah (if they do, I know it is a condition) with those who fight in the cause of satan.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So Muslimah, you support suicide bombings as a proper means of defense, if done so in the name of allah?

Does this extend to using children in suicide bombings as well?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Phat I am not supporting or opposing, this issue specailly is only judged by Allah. I am not Allah, I can never determine what is correct. But if we go Islamic way.

Women and children should not be killed during war.

I was just trying to tell Ibn we can not equate both sides calling them both terrorists. Phat everything in Islam depends on intention.

If the intention is for any other than Allah the deed is not accepted.

Even prayer imagine. If u pray to let people see u and say o wow he/she is a very religious person. Then tough luck u got your reward from humans like u in this world. nothing in the day after

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

o and phat, the criteria for us is scholars opinion.

In this regard, they had different views, some said it is halal (lawful) others said no it is not jihad.

For me I simply stop and say may Allah allow them to do jihad correctly ameen. Because it is a pity to loose a chance. In all cases we are going to die, so if u r able to attain a better position in the Day After, this will be the issue

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As far as i know of the issue... the scholars differ alot on this issue... there are those who say it is halaal and those who says that it is totally haraam...

It is also very noteworthy that of all the opinions that i have heard those who say that these martyrdom missions are halaal also say that it is only allowed in this situation... as far as i know the ruling by those who have studied only apply to this specific situation because of their position...

I am no scholar, and i cannot issue an opinion on this... however i must admit that for those who say that it is halaal i have not seen their daleel... if anyone can produce it then alhamdulillah...

there is a principle in fiqh that says.... "necessity makes hated deeds lawful" In other words we are allowed to do haraam acts if it is ABSOLUTELY NECESSARY... e.g. eating swine to save our lives...

In all applications of this principle of fiqh i have only seen the word "necessity" meaning "to save one's life" ... i have never heard it being used to justify suicide bombings....

my dad and i argue on this alot but i have not seen the proof for is sooo i cannot agree with it... all that i can do is make du'a for my brothers and sisters and hope that allah guides them and grants them victory in this jihaad....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now